Compare GoodCharlie vs. Payless Power
GoodCharlie is a certified Texas energy provider that offers fixed-rate and green energy plans, plus pet-friendly benefits. Payless Power is also a certified provider in Texas and sells both prepaid and postpaid electricity plans.
Both are good companies, but which is a better fit for your household depends on your needs. Let’s see how the two companies compare to help you make your choice.
GoodCharlie vs. Payless Power Savings Scores
| Category | GoodCharlie | Payless Power |
|---|---|---|
| Plan Options | 4 | 4 |
| Uniqueness of Audience | 5 | 5 |
| Customer Service | 2 | 2 |
| Accessibility | 5 | 5 |
| Extra Features | 5 | 5 |
| Total Energy Savings Score | 4.2/5 | 4.2/5 |
GoodCharlie excels at:
- Free pet benefits for customers
- Offers renewable energy plans
- Has cancellation fees as low as $20
Payless Power excels at:
- Quickly starts service on new accounts
- Provides plans that don’t check your credit or require deposits
- Offers flexible plans with no long-term contracts
GoodCharlie vs. Payless Power Electricity Plans & Rates
Energy plans and rates for GoodCharlie and Payless Power vary by location, but the charts below give an idea of what you might pay for different plans. Review GoodCharlie and Payless Power plans from Energy Savings side-by-side.
GoodCharlie Electricity Plans & Rates
Rates are in cents/kWh for 1000kWh usage. The prices may vary depending on the utility. Data is obtained from powertochoose.org (Power to Choose.) The data above is reflecting only English plans. Some plans shown on the table above may not be available through our site.
Payless Power Electricity Plans & Rates
Rates are in cents/kWh for 1000kWh usage. The prices may vary depending on the utility. Data is obtained from powertochoose.org (Power to Choose.) The data above is reflecting only English plans. Some plans shown on the table above may not be available through our site.
Additional Details about GoodCharlie vs. Payless Power
Below is a side-by-side table of plans available from GoodCharlie and Payless Power.
| Category | GoodCharlie |
Payless Power |
|---|---|---|
| Plan Types | Fixed-rate, renewable energy | Prepaid, fixed rate |
| Term Lengths Available | 12, 16, 24, 36 months | 6 or 12 months prepaid; 6, 1, 12, 24, 36 months for fixed-rate plans |
| Renewable Energy Options | Yes | No |
| Refer-A-Friend Rewards | Yes | No |
| Switch Plan Fees | Yes | Yes |
| Fixed Rate Plan Early Termination Fees | $20/month remaining in contract | $149 to $299 for fixed-rate plans |
*Last updated on Updated on September 19, 2026 based on plans showing on the respective energy provider’s website and powertochoose.org.
How to Choose the Right Texas Energy Company for You
Here are some questions you can ask yourself to find the best fit when comparing different electric companies:
- What’s your average energy usage?
- Are you searching for a longer-term commitment, somewhere around 48 to 60 months? Or do you want a shorter-term plan, closer to 12 months?
- If you were to cancel your electricity plan before your term is up, how much would you have to pay?
- Are the plans offered at a fixed or variable rate?
- What are an electric retail provider’s customer reviews?
- Does the company offer perks for loyal customers?
Choose GoodCharlie if…
You want free pet perks with your plan, like a free $750 emergency fund for your dog or cat or free 24/7 video calls with a licensed veterinarian.
Choose Payless Power if…
You want plans that don’t check your credit or require a deposit to enroll.
GoodCharlie vs. Payless Power Frequently Asked Questions
DON'T ADD A QUESTION HERE.
DON’T ADD CONTENT HERE.
Do GoodCharlie and Payless Power offer green energy options?
GoodCharlie offers green energy options through its GoodGreen plans, while Payless Power doesn’t have any green energy programs.
What time-of-use plans does GoodCharlie have?
GoodCharlie doesn’t offer any time-of-use plans; only fixed-rate plans, where energy rates remain the same throughout the contract.
Do GoodCharlie’s pet perks benefit animals other than dogs?
Yes, GoodCharlie’s pet perks are available to both cats and dogs and can be used for up to five pets in your household.
Does Payless Power only offer prepaid electricity plans?
No, Payless Power also offers traditional fixed-rate plans in addition to its prepaid electricity plans.